4e

If you honestly disagree that a particular thing in 4e is stupid, then disagree and explain why.

Mike Mearls Strangles Realism In D&D Like It’s An Unruly Hooker « Geek Related 2009

The optimization in 4e is far more statistically creative than you mention here.

D&D 4e’s Out… And It’s Awful. Here’s Why « Geek Related 2008

Furthermore, the problem is that the design philosophy in 4e makes it require way more house rules.

Mike Mearls Strangles Realism In D&D Like It’s An Unruly Hooker « Geek Related 2009

To sum: D&D 4e is in the spotlight whether 4e players like it or not, so continued critical attention is inevitable.

Mike Mearls Strangles Realism In D&D Like It’s An Unruly Hooker « Geek Related 2009

As for modelling a convincing world, there are a lot of little things in 4e that makes it inconsistent for that.

Why Complain About 4e? Stop the Edition Wars! « Geek Related 2009

Complaining about 4e is just that – complaining for the sake of complaining.

Why Complain About 4e? Stop the Edition Wars! « Geek Related 2009

Meant to say that using a standard attack against jurors makes NO LESS sense in 4e than in any other edition.

Why Complain About 4e? Stop the Edition Wars! « Geek Related 2009

Now 4e is making min/max the norm (as well as the design philosophies of later 3rd edition.)

Why Complain About 4e? Stop the Edition Wars! « Geek Related 2009

I imagine the fact that minis of all sorts are more readily available attribute to the fact that 4e is miniature based.

2009 ENnies Winners – Questionable At Best « Geek Related 2009

Yeah, I have to go with 4e is just a nerfed gaming system.

Mike Mearls Strangles Realism In D&D Like It’s An Unruly Hooker « Geek Related 2009