Antrobus

Part III of the Article then discusses the merits of the Tenth Circuit’s analysis in Antrobus.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

In In re Antrobus, the Tenth Circuit rejected carefully reasoned decisions from the Second and Ninth Circuits and held that crime victims could only obtain appellate relief if they show that the district court had made a “clear and indisputable” error.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

Kenny and Sue Antrobus lost a motion to have their daughter, Vanessa Quinn, recognized as a protected “crime victim” under the CVRA.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

In footnote 166, the article makes it sound as if, since In re Antrobus was decided, only the Fifth Circuit has decided that mandamus standards of review apply (and without providing any analysis “of its own”), while the Third and Eleventh Circuits have held that ordinary appellate review standards apply.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

On hand this weekend to share the memories will be Marcel Stellman, who produced The Ying-Tong Song and other Goons hit singles, and the playwright John Antrobus, who co-wrote scripts with Milligan.

The Goon Show must go on – 60 years since its first broadcast 2011

In fact, the Sixth Circuit in In re Acker has also held, citing to Antrobus, that mandamus standards apply.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

Unfortunately, in a recent decision the Tenth Circuit (In re Antrobus) parted company with those other circuits and eviscerated the appellate protections promised to crime victims.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

Part I explains the factual background surrounding Antrobus.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

Unfortunately, in a recent decision the Tenth Circuit In re Antrobus parted company with those other circuits and eviscerated the appellate protections promised to crime victims.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010

In fact, the Sixth Circuit in In re Acker has also held, citing to Antrobus, that mandamus standards apply.

The Volokh Conspiracy » A Crime Victim’s Right to Appellate Review? 2010